Prevalence
of Depression among Post-Menopausal Women of Uttarakhand
Anjana Williams1, Grace Singh2
1Senior Nursing Tutor, Mental Health Department,
Himalayan College of Nursing, SRHU Dehradun, Uttarakhand, India
2H.O.D. Mental Health Department, Himalayan College of
Nursing, Dehradun, SRHU Uttarakhand,
India
*Corresponding
Author Email: anjana_williams@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT:
A Quantitative
study was conducted to determine the prevalence of depression among
post-menopausal women in selected villages of Dehradun,
Uttarakhand. The purpose of the study was to study
psychological and physiological links between depression and postmenopausal in
women. The survey approach was adopted and 102
Post-menopausal women were
selected using Snowball sampling technique. The setting was selected through simple random sampling.
The present study adopted Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview
(MINI) scale to assess the depression level among the post-menopausal. Major
findings of the study revealed educational level of 61% had no education, and
all the women (100%) were house managers. Only a few (15%) subjects had gone
for surgical interventions for gynecological disorders. No subject was on
hormonal therapy. The study results revealed that 54% of study subjects had
major depressive disorder. Participants 55 % had trouble sleeping or waking in
the morning every day and 59% responded that they feel tired all the time. A recent study on the risk of
post-menopausal depression didn’t conclude or determine what exactly was
causing the depression in the study group. However, when the body goes through
such radical changes as menopause; it wouldn’t be surprising to observe acute
depression and even major depression due to the imbalance of hormones in the
body.
KEYWORDS: Post-
menopausal, MINI, Menopausal
INTRODUCTION:
With increasing
age women are at an increased risk for depression during the pre-menopausal
period to the post-menopausal period. The depression is caused by change in
hormones in a woman’s body.1 These hormonal changes may include
thyroid conditions, diabetes etc. Menopause is a time that has to be faced by
every female and the more women know about it, the better they will be to
manage it.1
During
menopause the body experiences great changes during this phase. Estrogen acts
as a hormonal antidepressant and with menopause the estrogen levels in a
woman’s body significantly declines. Menopause causes mood swings which are
proved by various scientific studies; it also suggests that women are at risk
for major depression during and after menopause.2
Menopause
begins between the ages of 45 and 55 years of age, the average age being of
menopause is 51. According to a study conducted by India-based Institute for
social and economic change, London’s Times reports that one in five women
residing in India are likely to experience menopause by the age of 41.3
Research has shown that 20% women reported distressing symptoms at
menopause, and 65% showed variation of symptoms.3
A study
conducted on prevalence of menopause in India revealed that total of 130
million Indian women is expected to live beyond the menopause into old age by
2015. Most menopausal women go untreated
or use unproven alternative therapies for symptoms they have during or after
menopause. 4
A study was
conducted on problems associated with menopause in Mangalore city, Karnataka,
South India. The significant signs included hot flushes, headache and urinary
tract infection, back pain, joint and muscle pain, insomnia, depression, mood
disturbances, etc.5 Experts believe that women are more prone
to develop depression secondary to hormonal changes that take place throughout
their lifetime including puberty, pregnancy, and menopause; as well as monthly
variations of the menstrual cycle.
Besides
hormonal fluctuations, other factors, such as reproductive, genetic,
interpersonal skills, and certain psychological and personality characteristics
increase women's vulnerability to the depressive disorder.6 As
menopause is a natural biological event in every woman’s life there is no way
to prevent it from occurring, it will happen.
But the risk
of diseases associated with estrogen loss can be reduced if the health care
personnel’s know the prevalence and occurrence of disorders associated with
post-menopause. Thus the researcher felt the necessity collecting the
information from the population regarding prevalence of depression among post-
menopausal women.
STATEMENT OF
THE PROBLEM:
A survey to
determine the prevalence of depression and associative symptoms among
post-menopausal women in selected villages of Dehradun,
Uttarakhand.
METHODOLOGY:
In present
study the survey approach was adopted. And study was conducted in Adarsh
Nagar Jolly Grant, Dehradun. Setting
was selected through simple random sampling. 102 Post-menopausal women were
selected using Snowball sampling technique. The data was obtained through
standard Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI) to assess the
depression level among the post-menopausal. The data was collected after taking
necessary administrative permissions from the concerned authorities and written
consent from the study participants.
RESULTS:
Collected Data
was analyzed and organized under following headings
1.Socio-demographic data of Study Subjects
2.Description of responses of Study Subjects in
Frequency and percentage
Table No –I
Socio-demographic data of Study Subjects
n=102
|
Variables |
Frequency
(f) |
Percentage
(%) |
|
Age 45-55 56-65 |
46 56 |
45 55 |
|
Educational
Status Nil < 10+2 Graduation |
63 33 6 |
61 32 7 |
|
Occupation Not Working |
102 |
100 |
|
Marital
Status Married Separated Widow Divorce |
92 01 07 02 |
90 01 07 02 |
|
Type of Family Nuclear Joint |
62 40 |
61 39 |
|
Children Yes |
102 |
100 |
|
Surgery Yes No |
15 87 |
15 85 |
|
Hormonal
therapy No |
102 |
100 |
Table no. I
depict that almost equal numbers of the subjects (45%) fell in the age group of
45 to 55 years. Among all the subjects most of the subjects (61%) had no formal
education. All the study subjects (100%) were house managers. Very few (15%)
subjects had surgical interventions for gynecological disorders during their
lifetime. Out of all subjects none was on hormonal therapy.
Table No –2
Description of Responses of Menopausal Women in Frequency and Percentage n=102
|
S.N |
Questions |
Statements |
Frequency (f) |
Percentage (%) |
|
1 |
A1 YES No |
Have you been consistently depressed or
down, most of the day, nearly every day, for the past two weeks? |
71 31 |
70 30 |
|
2. |
A2 YES No |
In the past two weeks, have you been much
less interested in most things or much less able to enjoy the things you used
to enjoy most of the time? |
55 47 |
54 46 |
*MINI
comprised of 3 questions, A1, A2, A3 the participants said no to A1, were not
questioned further for the symptoms
Data shown in
Table No. 2 describes the percentage level of responses given by respondents.
It shows that 70% of participants have said Yes to question A1 and 54% of study
subjects had responded yes to question No. A2. Hence it can be concluded that
most of postmenopausal women participated in the study were feeling depressed
and had lost interest in their daily chores which are the major significant
signs of developing depression.
Graph no.1
Percentage wise distribution of associative Symptoms of depression
Graph number 1
depicts the percentage of answers responded by the study subjects against the question
A3 and it revealed that 59% of participants feel tired and 55 % participants had trouble sleeping or
waking in the morning every day. Almost half 48% participants had difficulty in
concentrating in work and 34% participants reported that their appetite and
weight have changed in past two weeks. Study participants 28% had felt slowness
in movement and 31 % said that they feel guilty for mistakes of every day and
feeling of guilt were present in 24% of study participants. From the above data
it could be inferred that feeling of guilt, slowness in actions and trouble in
sleeping are the significant reasons which indicated signs of depression among
study participants.
CONCLUSION:
Experts
believe that women may be more prone to develop depression secondary to
hormonal changes that take place throughout their lifetime: puberty, pregnancy,
and menopause; as well as monthly variations of the menstrual cycle. Besides
hormonal fluctuations, other factors, such as reproductive, genetic,
interpersonal skills, and certain psychological and personality characteristics
increase women's vulnerability to the depressive disorder. Thus the study
concluded that postmenopausal women of Uttarakhand
experiences distressing symptoms including change in appetite, loss of interest
in normal activities and feeling of guilt which indicates that postmenopausal
depression is much significant among these women.
DISCUSSION:
The study
results revealed that almost equal numbers of the subjects 45% fell in the age
group of 45 to 55 years. Among all the subjects most of the subjects 61% had no
formal education. These study demographics are supported by the study
conducted by Rita Aaron et al.7, Vijayalakshmi
S. et al.11, Marleen C. Becht et al.12, Very few 15% subjects had
surgical interventions for gynecological disorders during their lifetime. Out
of all subjects none was on hormonal therapy which suggests that the symptoms
of depression are purely because of menopausal phase.
The study
results showed that 70% of postnatal women felt consistently depressed or down,
nearly every day, for the past two weeks and 54% of postnatal women were much
less interested in most things and were not able to enjoy the daily chores they
used to enjoy most of the time. It also revealed that 59% of women felt tired
without reason, 55 % had sleep disturbances. Almost half 48% women felt
difficulty in concentrating in work and 34% participants reported loss of
appetite which caused change in their weight in past two weeks. It was also
reported that 28% of women had felt slowness in their movement and 31 % had
feeling of guilt for every little errors or mistakes. The above stated
symptom’s points towards depression and these results are supported by the
study conducted by Marleen C. Becht
et al.,12 Sudhaa Sharma et al..9
REFERENCES:
1. American Heart Association (2004). Coronary
artery disease: Secondary prevention, retrieved on November 15, 2004 from: http://www.univerahealthcare.com/wny/pdf/ProvGuidelines/CADLipid .pdf
2. Bairy L, Adiga S, Bhat P and Bhat R. Prevalence of
menopausal symptoms and quality of life after menopause in women from South
India. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology,
2009 march 3; 49(1): 106 – 109
3. Carson JW, Carson KM, Porter LS, Keefe
FJ and Seewaldt VL. Yoga awareness
program for menopausal symptoms in breast cancer survivors: results from
randomized trial. Journal of the Multinational association of Supportive care
in cancer, 2009 October; 17(10):1301-1309.
4. Living with menopause,psychGuides.com, cited
on april 2012 Available from: URL http://www.psychguides.com/guides/living-with-menopause/ Article
5. Lina Alexandra Rosin, Relationship Between
Depression And Coronary Artery Disease In Postmenopausal Women, The University
Of Arizona 2005 Depression/Cad cited on May 2012 available from: URL https://w3.nursing.arizona.edu/scripts/ThesisDetail.asp?num=5391791222162005214252
6. Myths,Magic and Mystery, Supporting women’s health and
fertility, www.menstruation.com.au cited on april
2012. . Available from: URL: http://www.menstruation.com.au/contributors/moonflow.html
7. Rita Aaron, Jayaprakash
Muliyil, medico-social dimensions of menopause: A
cross sectional study. The National Medical Journal of India. Vol.15, no.1,
2012
8. Scottsdale Psychiatrist cited on april 2012 Available From: URL Http://Psychiatristscottsdale.Com/Post-Menopausal-Depression/
9. Sudhaa Sharma, Vishal R.Tandon, Annil Mahajan PG Deptt. of Obstetrics
& Gynaecology, Pharmacology & Therapeutics
General Medicine, GMC, Jammu, J&K, India, Vol. 9 No. 1, January-March
2007
10. Syamala TS, Sivakami M.
Menopause: An emerging issue in India.Economic and
political weekly. 2005 Nov 19; 40. (47): 4923.
11. Vijayalakshmi S., Ramesh Chandrababu & Eilean Victoria
l. menopausal transition among northern indian women.
Nitte University Journal of Health Science. NUJHS
Vol. 3, No.2, June 2013, ISSN 2249-7110.
12. Marleen C. Becht, Cecile
F. Van Erp, Tineke M. Teeuwisse, Guus L. Van Heck,
Maarten J. Van Son, and Victor J. Pop. Measuring depression in women around
menopausal age towards a validation of the Edinburgh Depression Scale. Journal
of Affective Disorders 63 (2001) 209–213 Utrecht, the Netherlands,
Diagnostic Center of Eindhoven, Eindhoven, The Netherlands
13. Sudhaa Sharma, Vishal R.Tandon, Annil Mahajan. Menopausal Symptoms in Urban Women.journal of J K science Vol. 9 No. 1, January-March
2007
Received on 04.11.2015 Modified on 26.11.2015
Accepted on 08.12.2015 © A&V Publications all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research. 2016; 6(4): 421-424.
DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2016.00079.3